4A’s Transformation Recap: Day 2

The 4A’s Transformation conference came to a climax Wednesday in Austin, Texas, and the day began with what many attendees considered the event’s main attraction: a panel discussion featuring holding company CEOs Michael Roth (IPG), Martin Sorrell (WPP), and John Wren (Omnicom Group), moderated by Brian Perkins from Johnson & Johnson. The conversation covered topics from the holding company model to acquisitions and collaboration to content ownership, but the most passionate dialogue surrounded the issues of talent development and diversity.

All three concurred that the industry as a whole needs to do a better job of recruiting and developing top talent, with Sorrell noting that the current trend of simply poaching talent from competing agencies is counterproductive to grooming future leaders. Roth chimed in and agreed, but also pointed out that IPG has made diversity a major priority. Sorrell countered by repeatedly asking Roth if there was a Chief Talent Officer on the IPG board and then stated that he felt the holding companies were simply “paying lip service” to the issue. Roth quickly responded: “Maybe you are, but we’re not.”

On the subject of the holding company format, all three executives agreed that acquisitions will remain an important part of the future, though they all stated a preference for more organic, internal growth. Technological and digital advances were also a focal point, with Wren stating that he anticipates a total integration of traditional and digital marketing within two years, doubting that agencies will still have Chief Digital Officers at that time. Roth shared a similar perspective when he stated that digital must be ingrained into the DNA of all parts of the business, but he felt the opportunity for specialists and digitally-focused agencies would likely remain.

The discussion ended with the three sharing their views on what role clients can play in the fostering of stronger relationships. Wren pleaded with clients to trust the agencies and frankly suggested that they should “pat someone on the back instead of prying $5 from their wallets.” In a rare moment of agreement, Sorrell stated that praising agencies when they do good work goes a long way in improving morale. Roth opined that both sides get the most out their symbiotic relationship when they view each other as partners with common goals.

After the CEO panel was a one-on-one interview with Miles Nadal, Founder, Chairman, & CEO of MDC Partners Inc. He followed up on the above discussion by stating that he believes the role of the CEO is synonymous with Chief Talent Officer, and he shared his views on the underestimated impact of social media and being accountable to clients who are seeking a return on the investments they make with their agency partners.

The second half of the morning’s program kicked off with a panel on television programming, with executives from AMC, History and Lifetime Networks, and Science Channel and Animal Planet discussing the future of what is still the biggest and most important screen that advertisers use to reach consumers. All felt that the use of social media to connect with viewers changes the game, though Nancy Dubuc (History and Lifetime) said that a show’s potential social media reach doesn’t determine whether or not it will be green-lighted. The importance of Netflix and streaming video services was also touched upon, though Charlie Collier (AMC) said, “we don’t’ dive in for the pennies,” with Dubuc agreeing that the main focus remains on TV screens and Nielsen ratings.

Geomentum CEO Sean Finnegan took part in a discussion on mobility and place-based business models, focusing on how local marketing is being transformed by emerging platforms. On the topic of new engagement standards, Finnegan stated that the universe of new technologies has added measurement complexity; however, Geomentum continues to focus on the most important metric to its clients: sales and business results.

Next was an eye-opening look at the present and future of gaming as presented by Ken Simon from Microsoft, a UM client. He took attendees through a close look at the “war for the living room,” providing staggering numbers on the reach, ever-expanding scope of the gaming target audience through innovations such as Kinect, and innovative means advertisers can use to appeal to consumers.

The day’s last discussion centered around new advertising guidelines, particularly as it pertains to digital marketing. All speakers agreed that it is of the utmost importance for the advertising industry to properly police itself in this realm, or run the risk of the federal government intervening and constructing strict guidelines that could limit the effectiveness of targeted marketing.

Transformation 2011 provided opportunities to think about the present and future states of the media, advertising, and marketing worlds, and IPG, Mediabrands, and their affiliated agencies were crucial to the discussion.
Special thanks to Jonathan Nierman at Mediabrands for this recap. Check out Mediabrands online at www.facbeook.com/mediabrands